Article 39 is pleased to announce that we have been granted permission by the High Court to intervene in a judicial review brought by the Maggie Oliver Foundation against the Home Secretary, challenging the government’s failure to implement recommendations made by the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA).
Our intervention focuses on the government’s continued failure to prohibit the use of pain-inducing restraint on children in custody, despite IICSA’s recommendation in 2022 that these techniques should be recognised as a form of child abuse and banned.
Article 39 has been granted permission to submit written legal arguments and a witness statement from our Executive Director, Jodie Wickers. Our intervention draws on our longstanding work challenging the deliberate infliction of pain on children in custody, highlighting the serious physical and psychological harm caused by these techniques, the inadequacy of existing safeguards, and the significant barriers children face in recognising, reporting and challenging abuse in institutional settings.
We firmly believe that the deliberate infliction of pain on children is a form of child abuse and that its continued authorisation is incompatible with children’s rights to protection from violence, abuse and degrading treatment.
The hearing is scheduled to take place in November 2026.
Jodie Wickers, Executive Director at Article 39 said:
“There is no justification for deliberately inflicting pain on children in the name of their care or protection. Children in custody are among the most vulnerable in our society. They should be able to depend on the adults responsible for their care to keep them safe, protect them from harm and support their recovery. Instead, those same adults are authorised to hurt them.
Pain-inducing restraint is fundamentally incompatible with children’s rights. It creates a culture of fear and intimidation and undermines the trusting relationships essential to children’s safety and wellbeing. Evidence repeatedly shows that safeguards intended to restrict its use are ineffective or not followed. Yet rather than meeting IICSA’s recommendation to ban these techniques, the government has escalated the use of pain by rolling out PAVA incapacitant sprays in child prisons.
We welcome the opportunity to put evidence before the Court and hope this legal challenge will bring an end to these abusive practices once and for all. It is long past time for the government to recognise that children in custody deserve the same protection from violence and abuse as every other child.”
